Baseball Jewelry

Gift yourself or your loved one baseball-inspired pieces to show how much you care.

Skip to results list
Showing 68 items

Filter & Sort

Sort by
  • Baseball - Saint Christopher Doubledside Sports Religious Medal

    Baseball - Saint Christopher Doubledside Sports Religious Medal

    Baseball - Saint Christopher Doubledside Sports Religious Medal

     From $49.95
  • Baseball - Saint Sebastian Doubledside Sports Religious Medal

    Baseball - Saint Sebastian Doubledside Sports Religious Medal

    Baseball - Saint Sebastian Doubledside Sports Religious Medal

     From $49.95
  • Saint Sebastian Baseball Medal

    Saint Sebastian Baseball Medal

    Saint Sebastian Baseball Medal

     From $29.95
  • Baseball Bat Cross Pendant w/ 20 inch Chain

    Baseball Bat Cross Pendant w/ 20 inch Chain

    Baseball Bat Cross Pendant w/ 20 inch Chain

     From $44.95
  • Stainless Steel Personalized Baseball Bead Bracelet

    Stainless Steel Personalized Baseball Bead Bracelet

    Stainless Steel Personalized Baseball Bead Bracelet
    $39.95
    $39.95
  • Sterling Silver Heart Shaped Mom Baseball Pendant w/ Number & Chain

    Sterling Silver Heart Shaped Mom Baseball Pendant w/ Number & Chain

    Sterling Silver Heart Shaped Mom Baseball Pendant w/ Number & Chain

     From $84.95
  • Saint Rita Baseball Medal

    Saint Rita Baseball Medal

    Saint Rita Baseball Medal

     From $29.95
  • Baseball Stitched Saint Sebastian Enameled Cross Pendant w/ Number

    Baseball Stitched Saint Sebastian Enameled Cross Pendant w/ Number

    Baseball Stitched Saint Sebastian Enameled Cross Pendant w/ Number

     From $109.95
  • Personalized Baseball Jersey Number Necklace with Name

    Personalized Baseball Jersey Number Necklace with Name

    Personalized Baseball Jersey Number Necklace with Name

     From $49.95
  • Personalized Sterling Silver Baseball Glove Pendant

    Personalized Sterling Silver Baseball Glove Pendant

    Personalized Sterling Silver Baseball Glove Pendant

     From $119.95
  • Personalized 3D Baseball Helmet Keychain

    Personalized 3D Baseball Helmet Keychain

    Personalized 3D Baseball Helmet Keychain
    $44.95
    $44.95
  • Color Enameled Baseball Number Charm Necklace or Pendant w/ 18 inch Chain

    Color Enameled Baseball Number Charm Necklace or Pendant w/ 18 inch Chain

    Color Enameled Baseball Number Charm Necklace or Pendant w/ 18 inch Chain

     From $34.95
  • Saint Christopher Baseball Medal

    Saint Christopher Baseball Medal

    Saint Christopher Baseball Medal

     From $39.95
  • Stainless Steel Personalized Baseball Number Bangle Bracelet

    Stainless Steel Personalized Baseball Number Bangle Bracelet

    Stainless Steel Personalized Baseball Number Bangle Bracelet
    $49.95
    $49.95
  • Baseball Stitched Saint Sebastian Enameled Cross Pendant w/ Number

    Baseball Stitched Saint Sebastian Enameled Cross Pendant w/ Number

    Baseball Stitched Saint Sebastian Enameled Cross Pendant w/ Number

     From $79.95
  • Custom Baseball Pendant w/ Number

    Custom Baseball Pendant w/ Number

    Custom Baseball Pendant w/ Number

     From $64.95
  • Engraving a photo locket in the studio

    Made to Order in Our New Jersey Studio

    We craft every piece in our New Jersey studio, using durable, high-quality materials from American suppliers, keeping production and shipping close to home.
  • Silver Personalized Baseball Stitch Heart Photo Locket

    Silver Personalized Baseball Stitch Heart Photo Locket

    Silver Personalized Baseball Stitch Heart Photo Locket

     From $89.95
  • Personalized 3D Baseball Home Plate Pendant w/ Number

    Personalized 3D Baseball Home Plate Pendant w/ Number

    Personalized 3D Baseball Home Plate Pendant w/ Number
    $49.95
    $49.95
  • Baseball Bat Cross Pendant with Number w/ 20 inch Chain

    Baseball Bat Cross Pendant with Number w/ 20 inch Chain

    Baseball Bat Cross Pendant with Number w/ 20 inch Chain

     From $94.95
  • Baseball Stitch Cross Pendant

    Baseball Stitch Cross Pendant

    Baseball Stitch Cross Pendant

     From $64.95
  • Personalized Baseball Bat W/ Number

    Personalized Baseball Bat W/ Number

    Personalized Baseball Bat W/ Number

     From $49.95
  • Color Enameled Baseball Number Charm or Pendant with 2 Digits

    Color Enameled Baseball Number Charm or Pendant with 2 Digits

    Color Enameled Baseball Number Charm or Pendant with 2 Digits

     From $74.95
  • Saint Rita Religious Medal "Baseball Religious Medal"

    Saint Rita Religious Medal "Baseball Religious Medal"

    Saint Rita Religious Medal "Baseball Religious Medal"

     From $49.95
  • Baseball Jersey Charm or Pendant w/ Name & Number

    Baseball Jersey Charm or Pendant w/ Name & Number

    Baseball Jersey Charm or Pendant w/ Name & Number

     From $84.95
  • Personalized Round Baseball Pendant with Cross Charm w/ Chain Included

    Personalized Round Baseball Pendant with Cross Charm w/ Chain Included

    Personalized Round Baseball Pendant with Cross Charm w/ Chain Included
    $119.95
    $119.95
  • Sterling Silver Baseball Bat Cross Pendant w/ 20 inch Chain

    Sterling Silver Baseball Bat Cross Pendant w/ 20 inch Chain

    Sterling Silver Baseball Bat Cross Pendant w/ 20 inch Chain

     From $109.95
  • Custom Round Baseball Pendant w/ Bat Cross Charm

    Custom Round Baseball Pendant w/ Bat Cross Charm

    Custom Round Baseball Pendant w/ Bat Cross Charm

     From $84.95
  • Sterling Silver Saint Sebastian Sided Baseball Oval Religious Medal w/ Chain

    Sterling Silver Saint Sebastian Sided Baseball Oval Religious Medal w/ Chain

    Sterling Silver Saint Sebastian Sided Baseball Oval Religious Medal w/ Chain

     From $94.95
  • Baseball Stitch Enameled Cross Pendant w/ Number

    Baseball Stitch Enameled Cross Pendant w/ Number

    Baseball Stitch Enameled Cross Pendant w/ Number

     From $64.95
  • Baseball Bat Cross Pendant w/ 20 inch Chain

    Baseball Bat Cross Pendant w/ 20 inch Chain

    Baseball Bat Cross Pendant w/ 20 inch Chain

     From $109.95
  • Personalized Star of David Baseball Enameled Pendant

    Personalized Star of David Baseball Enameled Pendant

    Personalized Star of David Baseball Enameled Pendant

     From $34.95
  • Personalized Baseball Homeplate Cut-Out with Number Pendant or Charm

    Personalized Baseball Homeplate Cut-Out with Number Pendant or Charm

    Personalized Baseball Homeplate Cut-Out with Number Pendant or Charm

     From $79.95
  • High Polished Baseball Cross w/ Number

    High Polished Baseball Cross w/ Number

    High Polished Baseball Cross w/ Number

     From $54.95
  • Sterling Silver Heart Shaped Baseball Pendant w/ Number & Chain

    Sterling Silver Heart Shaped Baseball Pendant w/ Number & Chain

    Sterling Silver Heart Shaped Baseball Pendant w/ Number & Chain

     From $84.95
  • Personalized Baseball Necklace w/ Chain Included

    Personalized Baseball Necklace w/ Chain Included

    Personalized Baseball Necklace w/ Chain Included

     From $49.95
  • Personalized 3D Baseball Bat Pendant with 18" Chain

    Personalized 3D Baseball Bat Pendant with 18" Chain

    Personalized 3D Baseball Bat Pendant with 18" Chain

     From $74.95